-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- smt007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueComing to Terms With AI
In this issue, we examine the profound effect artificial intelligence and machine learning are having on manufacturing and business processes. We follow technology, innovation, and money as automation becomes the new key indicator of growth in our industry.
Box Build
One trend is to add box build and final assembly to your product offering. In this issue, we explore the opportunities and risks of adding system assembly to your service portfolio.
IPC APEX EXPO 2024 Pre-show
This month’s issue devotes its pages to a comprehensive preview of the IPC APEX EXPO 2024 event. Whether your role is technical or business, if you're new-to-the-industry or seasoned veteran, you'll find value throughout this program.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - smt007 Magazine
Build Tariff Planning into Product Development Strategy Early
February 22, 2024 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 MagazineEstimated reading time: 6 minutes
An attorney at DesignCon? I wasn’t sure I heard that right either, but it’s true. I sat down for an interview with international trade lawyer James Kim of ArentFox Schiff LLP. James was at the show to present a session entitled “Chips, Batteries & Charging Stations,” which highlights the Biden administration’s steps to secure the supply chain for the EV industry.
James gave me a quick primer on international tariffs and trade laws, and he explained why design teams and manufacturers should consider import compliance early on in their product development to reduce risk and product cost.
Andy Shaughnessy: I'm here at DesignCon with James Kim of ArentFox Schiff LLP. James is an international trade attorney, and the first one I've met at a trade show. So, what brings you to DesignCon, James?
James Kim: That’s a good question. I may be the only attorney here at DesignCon! I'm speaking at the conference, and we have a session called Chips, Batteries and Charging Stations. Its focus is on how the Biden administration is taking steps to secure the supply chain for the EV industry. We thought that would be of interest to attendees here even though most of the folks are engineers rather than policy people. When it comes to trade issues or government incentives for the industry, these policies affect everybody all the way down to how you design your products and how you are sourcing your components. So, it's really important for everyone in this industry to be aware.
Shaughnessy: You said that your clients range from large OEMs all the way down to tier one and tier two manufacturers. What do they come to you for?
Kim: These companies are affected by things like the special tariffs on Chinese imports. Sometimes, the issue is that their imports are being scrutinized under some of the anti-forced labor provisions that are out there, which can cause big problems if you can't get your shipment across the border or your products are detained by authorities.
Chip makers, for instance, have to deal with some of the more stringent export controls that have been put on chips that are exported out of the US, especially the more advanced chips. Whether it's import rules, export rules, or the incentives under the Inflation Reduction Act, a lot of these companies are trying to figure out how they can minimize their risk. In addition, they’re also asking, “How do I put myself in a more strategic position so I can save some costs and maybe mitigate some of the tariffs or trade enforcement that my products might be subject to? How can I make better sourcing decisions?” They are searching for a competitive advantage by really understanding how these trade rules and different laws around incentives are going to affect them.
Shaughnessy: Every country has a different relationship with the US, so you have to understand all of them: the US-China relationship, US-Korea, US-EU.
Kim: Yes, and it takes a while to really get your arms around them. I've been doing this for many years. I worked for the government at U.S. Customs for almost seven years. Unbeknownst to many, that agency is actually one of the largest law enforcement agencies in the U.S. They have their hands in lot of things. Anything that comes across the border must go through Customs and Border Protection (CBP).
As a CBP lawyer, I advised the agency on issues like admissibility, tariffs, and other import matters. We ran into a lot of interesting issues, but it can be overwhelming for a layperson to try to understand them all, especially when the rules change so rapidly. On the export front, there have been a whole slew of rules on export controls that have come out in just the last couple of years. It is hard to keep track of. That’s why companies come to lawyers like us, to try to make sense of it all, to help keep them out of trouble, and to support the bottom-line when it comes to saving costs by minimizing some of their tariff exposure.
Shaughnessy: American assembly providers are getting killed by tariffs on every little component now, like discretes. This hurts the small manufacturers who can't pass that cost onto their customers. What does it take to change these tariffs? Is it a matter of who screams the loudest?
Kim: Sometimes it's that, but it's also knowing what avenues are out there for you to affect change. Let's say you have a specific product that is affected by those China special tariffs, which are often as high as 25%. The government has, from time to time, come out with ways to allow companies to request an exclusion from some of those tariffs. There is a whole process for submitting a request to get an exclusion from those high tariffs on China imports. We have helped companies successfully obtain those exclusions. Right now, the US Trade Representative is doing a review of those China special tariffs to see whether they're going to extend them, and, in some cases, increase or decrease them. We are still waiting to see how that is going to pan out. But during that process, the government has allowed companies to submit comments, to get their voices heard. We're helping companies make their case by arguing that some of those exclusions should remain in place.
Shaughnessy: What are some of the common mistakes made by companies? How do you advise people who are importing parts from places like China?
Kim: Import compliance is often an afterthought. It's considered something that you do at the end of the process after you design your product, figure out sourcing, and come up with a strategy to bring your product to market. Then you deal with the compliance. But what companies may be failing to see is that if they understand these rules from the get-go and incorporate them into their product strategy, they can avoid a mess later on. They can avoid the higher tariffs, avoid CBP scrutiny and fines or being subject to an audit. The savvier companies who come to us early on in their process have been able to work their way around these rules in a way that meets their needs.
Shaughnessy: Right after the lead-free RoHS legislation in the EU went into effect, a shipment of PlayStations coming into Europe for the Christmas season was seized because they had leaded solder. I think it was worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
Kim: That’s right. It can be as easy as that if you are found to be non-compliant.
Shaughnessy: James, this has really been fascinating. Thank you for your time.
Kim: Thank you for the opportunity to talk about this. I’m looking forward to attending some of the DesignCon sessions myself. I find it all fascinating from my perspective. I’m glad to be here and am learning a lot.
Suggested Items
Cypress Industries Expands PCB, High Level Assembly in Mexico
04/09/2021 | PRNewswireCypress Industries has added additional Printed Circuit Board Assembly (PCBA) lines and expanded our High Level Assembly (HLA) footprint at our Mexico plant in order to handle additional volume.
Variosystems Expands in Mexico
02/19/2021 | Variosystems AGVariosystems is constantly looking for new ways to provide complete flexibility to its customers. With the 2020 pandemic, the tariffs on China products and the high intercontinental transport costs, it became clear that there was a need for a North-American high volume facility able to support labor intensive assemblies.
American Polysilicon Manufacturers Praise Phase 1 of U.S.-China Trade Deal
01/16/2020 | GlobeNewswireThe United States’ three remaining manufacturers of polysilicon today thanked President Trump and praised U.S. negotiators for securing the Chinese commitment to purchase U.S. polysilicon in the Phase 1 U.S.-China trade deal, while noting any benefit for U.S. manufacturers and workers will depend on how China implements the agreement.
The Big Picture: Globalization—Tariffs and Alternate Sources
01/09/2020 | Mehul Davé -- Column: The Big PictureThe new year is upon us, so Mehul Davé started thinking about the main challenges his company and customers are facing as we enter 2020: tariffs and finding alternate sources for PCBs. Mehul shares his thoughts.
One World, One Industry: Rising Tariffs Put a Painful Squeeze on Electronics Manufacturers
12/23/2019 | John Mitchell -- Column: One World, One IndustryIPC recognizes that you are greatly affected by the ongoing tariff dispute between China and the United States. To date, the two countries have imposed tariffs on hundreds of billions of dollars in imports in a tit for tat that could escalate further if an agreement is not reached soon. Dr. John Mitchell discusses IPC's recent survey of U.S. members and the organization's perspective.